The idea for this post came to me last night on a wave of inspiration after my husband said “don’t judge a book by it’s cover!” I don’t remember what he was talking about, but my first thought was, that’d make a great post, because that’s actually a really stupid saying, as forward thinking as it tries to be. The truth of the matter is pretty near everyone judges books by their covers; it’s inevitable. The cover art is the very first thing, and if it grabs your attention, you turn the book to read the synopsis on the back. If *that* grabs you, then you read the first page, or a random few in the middle to see if the book is worth reading. Or at least, that’s the order I go with. I’m usually very reluctant to give a novel a chance, if the cover doesn’t give me a visual of what to expect out of the story.
I think that most authors and publishers are aware of the importance of cover art to their novel, and I’ve seen many artists over the last few months, jumping with anticipation at seeing the new art for their novels, or sharing with pride what artists have come up with. This is how it should be! Even self published authors generally try, or should try, to make an effort at creating their own eye catching covers; Photoshop is your friend!
Every once in a while, though, you have to wonder what the author or publisher was
thinking when they chose the cover they did. Bad covers range from the (unintentionally) extremely boring, to the unfortunately drawn, to those that misrepresent the novel’s contents. There is also the intentionally boring, i.e. plain, covers that I’m
not a huge fan of, either, but usually in those cases publishers still manage to make plain look interesting; the right font and colors can go a long way; the cover for Cryptonomicon comes to mind. Do you see how the subtle lines on the dark background draw you in, and the brightness of the title just pops? The image makes the novel feel mysterious and intriguing and leaves you wondering, what could this novel be about? Before you even begin to read, the atmosphere of the novel is created by the cover.
These two cover examples bring me to another point. Cover art should be ART. If you look at these two covers, the first may convey more information about the novel than the second, (as far as there might be a gun, a knife and a stick (baseball bat?) in it,) but it’s just not pretty – it’s not art. I tend to dislike book covers that are simple photographs, unless the photograph is well enough done to qualify as art. The image above does not, and as such, it flops.
The cover is your novel’s first impression; what the audience sees on the outside, they expect to read on the inside. Even well drawn cover art needs to be careful, however of
what the cover portrays. There are plenty elegantly drawn covers which just don’t fit into the story. For example, Terry Brook’s Genesis of Shannara series all feature a scene from the novel as the cover art. However, the cover art for Elves of Cintra shows the main character standing in front of the cave of the ice dragon, holding a burning torch. The problem with this, is that this series takes place not long after armageddon, in a time when technology still works – this series represents a switch from sci-fi to fantasy in the Shannara universe. So, in reality, in this scene the main character is carrying a flash light, and not wearing fantasy-style clothes. I actually remember talking to my husband about this when I read the novel. I was unimpressed with the lack of attention to detail on behalf of the artist.
Anyway, this is, by far, not the only blog or website to point out unfortunate novel covers, so I’d like to give others a nod. The most memorable, for me, is a comedy piece that Cracked.com did on the Best (worst) Fantasy and Science Fiction Book Covers. I like this article the best because of the author’s humorous reasons of why the cover is so bad. Most bad cover art sites just list thumbnails of bad covers, but I did find an exception that I’m definitely going to have to spend more time going through archives, because the front page was enough to hook me. It’s kinda like Cakewrecks, but for books; Judge a Book By it’s Cover does exactly that, and it’s really quite funny.